Employers
4 min read

Virtual Mental Health vs. Traditional EAPs: What Employers Should Know

Updated on September 3, 2025

Virtual Mental Health vs. Traditional EAPs: What Employers Should Know-featured-image

When it comes to supporting employee well-being, both  virtual mental health services and Employee Assistance Programs (EAPs) aim to provide access to care. But they’re not the same — and understanding the differences can help employers choose the right solution for their team.

What Are Traditional EAPs?

EAPs are typically bundled into insurance or offered as standalone services. They provide limited free sessions (often 3–6) with mental health professionals and support for issues like stress, grief, or substance abuse. While valuable in theory, most EAPs suffer from:

  • Low engagement (often <5%)
  • Limited access to therapists with long wait times
  • Lack of awareness among employees

How Virtual Mental Health Is Different

Virtual mental health services, like those offered by First Stop Health are designed for ease of access and ongoing care. Employees can:

  • Schedule phone or video therapy as soon as next day
  • Choose from a network of licensed providers
  • Access care confidentially through a simple mobile app
  • Receive ongoing support beyond just a few sessions
  • Care continuity with the same provider

It’s high-quality, stigma-free care that meets people where they are.

Which One Works Better?

For employers focused on outcomes, virtual mental health solutions often drive 5–10x higher engagement than traditional EAPs. That means more employees are actually getting help, and organizations see measurable benefits like reduced absenteeism, improved morale, and lower healthcare claims.

Final Word

Traditional EAPs can be a good starting point but they’re rarely enough on their own. Virtual mental health solutions offer a more scalable, accessible way to support employees’ emotional well-being in real time.

Looking to upgrade your mental health benefits?
See how First Stop Health can help ›

 

Virtual Care Calander
Improve outcomes and simplify employee benefits.

As virtual care evolves, employers face a key question: Do your digital health solutions actually work together — or are they just a patchwork of point solutions?

Learn Why Integration Matters

 

 

 

 

Table of contents

    Related Articles

    Virtual doctor conducting consult
    Employers
    Mental Health
    Urgent Care
    Savings
    Benefits Consultants
    Primary Care
    Why Employers Should Offer Virtual Care to All Workers

    For increased productivity and employee retention, employers should consider broadening virtual heal...

    Female patient waving with hand and speaking into tablet for video call with healthcare provider
    Employers
    Mental Health
    Benefits Consultants
    5 Ways to Get Employees to Utilize Employer-Sponsored Mental Health Programs

    The most effective mental health resources are those that fully engage employees. Here's how to get ...

    business people smiling
    Employers
    Savings
    Employers Struggle to Measure the ROI of Healthcare Benefits

    Most employers are not measuring the return on investment (ROI) of many of the most commonly offered...